They are completely different approaches.
As they did in the above epidemiological studies.
Why not?
Too bad you didn't watch this evening's BBC television programme "Alternative Medicine".
Here's a very brief synopsis. More info' at the link below.
'Programme 3: Herbalism
Kathy Sykes continues her investigation of Alternative Medicine, this time looking at the ancient practice of herbalism - and discovers that some herbs do indeed have powerful healing properties. Indeed, some may even offer answers to medical conditions that baffle modern science.
Kathy travels through South Africa, Germany and Britain. Everywhere there are distinct herbal traditions, each with their unique practices and distinctive plants. But one claim underlies them all - herbs have remarkable properties that make them powerful medicines.
In South Africa, she learns about a herb which is being touted as a new weapon in the fight against HIV-AIDS. She listens to the stories of patients and their carers who claim it is saving lives.
In Britain she meets people who are pinning their hopes on herbs - some with remarkable results. And in Germany she meets the scientists who are taking them apart and submitting them to rigorous clinical trials. Out of this has emerged at least eight 'super herbs'; herbs that in clinical trials performed so well that may give their pharmaceutical compebreastors a run for their money.
So, what's their secret? Working with fellow scientists, Kathy discovers that plants contain much more than a single - or even two or three - active ingredients. They are enormously complex chemical chickentails that have medicinal properties modern pharmaceuticals simply can't reproduce.
Training, employment, ...
not
